Talinn, 31 juillet – 3 août 2014
Sylvie Ayimpam, Andrea Ceriana Mayneri, Maixant Mébiame-Zomo, Roberto Beneduce, Jacky Bouju, Mirjam de Bruijn, membres du programme ANR EInSA, participeront à la Conférence européenne des anthropologues sociaux, dans le panel intitulé : Conflicts and social violence in an interconnected and uncertain world.
Programme de l’atelier :
Sylvie Ayimpam (Institut des Mondes Africains (IMAf)
Roberto Beneduce (University of Turin)
Jacky Bouju ( Aix Marseille Université)
This panel is concerned with the role of ordinary social violence in the emergence of what one could characterize as a « culture of uncertainty » that deeply sways social bonds and the individual conception of future, wealth or work of people. It is fashionable to say that new forms of intimacy are generated through intensified interconnected modes of cooperation. But, should it be assumed that these interconnections favour quiet and informed interrelations? In contemporary societies — characterized by sharp economic inequalities, social fragmentation and cultural heterogeneity — uncertainty also arise from the interconnection with the rest of the world. One of the main issues about the « intimacy of interconnected worlds » concerns consent: is it wanted by both sides and chosen with free consent ? If not really consented, intimacy can generate tensions and conflicts revealing power inequalities and interests discrepancies giving way to ordinary violence. The objective is to understand the role of ordinary violence and its dynamics in the reordering of social relationships in interconnected and uncertain societies. One of the issues concerns its potentiality: does ordinary violence open opportunities for the re-ordering of social relationships and world visions? Or, does it have disruptive and uncontrollable effects on social order? The contributions expected in this panel should be grounded on fieldwork records of uncertainty conceptions, conflicts and related ordinary violence expressions in different social settings in different parts of the world: life histories, case studies of witchcraft accusation, land tenure and inheritance conflicts, conflicts between neighbours, parents, friends or colleagues, etc.
An interconnected dimension of daily violence: how is experience of violence influenced by ICT?
Authors: Catherina Wilson ( Leiden University)
Mirjam de Bruijn (Institute of History)
Inge Butter (African Studies Center/Universiteit Leiden)
The point of departure is the border zones of Middle Africa where we have been witnessing horrible violence as a consequence of state collapse. This violence can be understood in a long history of war and oppression that is unfortunately part of the region’s dynamics. Today people have to stay in place because violence does not allow them to move, or they get stuck in refugee camps. This forced immobility is contradicting the dynamics of previous forced displacement. Hence immobility becomes a form of violence for those who are used to move. But for them accessibility of mobile telephony has been an interesting but ambiguous interference with their violent immobility to cope with life and identification. However, mobile phones may also be carriers of messages and rumours that are part of and perpetuate conflict dynamics. These information flows will contain people in their immobility. We are interested how this tool to communicate, link up and carry information feeds into the feelings of (im)mobility of the immobile mobiles and how this plays on their sociality and psychology. Whether this leads to experiencing more or less violence/violent acts is at the core of this paper.
Coming to terms with the present: land disputes as social spaces for redefining the rules of living together in the aftermath of the Sierra Leonean war
Author: Anais Ménard
The decade-long civil war (1991-2002) in Sierra Leone produced profound ruptures in social and family bonds. Rebel intimidation tactics such as rape, maiming and execution shattered provincial communities. The conflict also caused massive population displacements, transforming the ways people perceive their attachments to local networks. On the Peninsula of Freetown, permanent in-migrations have considerably reshaped the contours of social and political relationships. Towards the end of the war and during the following decade in particular, Sierra Leoneans from the interior moved to Freetown and nearby coastal communities in search of new opportunities. With rising demand for land, tensions have developed between local populations and settlers, stirring autochthonous claims and exclusive definitions of ethnicity. Land pressure causes disputes between relatives and long-standing neighbors. In the context of changing demography, tensions appear between populations who consider themselves autochthonous and well-established pre-war migrants, who start to lay claims to land that they previously considered belonging to local communities. Yet, this paper argues that local land disputes open up a new social space for discussing issues of inter- and intra-community violence. Land disputes, as they involve people who know each other well, have a short-term disruptive character for social life. Yet, they are also privileged spaces to talk about changing relations between individuals and between groups. Local land disputes allow people to reflect on the violence of the Sierra Leonean conflict, its consequences on contemporary social life, and to redefine the rules of living together in a rapidly changing socio-political context.
Conflicts inside NGOs for prevention of domestic violence in Tajikistan
Lucia Direnberger (Université Paris Diderot)
After the collapse of the USSR and civil war researchers observe and analyze violence domestic which is a mass phenomenon in Tadjikistan. For several years now local NGOs working in the field of prevention of domestic violence and supported by international donors have been working with mullahs.
Based on ethnographic research (interviews and participant observations) in NGOs between 2010 and 2012 in south of Tajikistan, I would like to anlayse tensions and conflicts produced by collaborations between NGOs’ members. Althought local NGOs and international donors promote this collaboration, during my fieldwork I observed contradictory positions. Religious leaders working in these NGOs do not share the same positions on gender issues : women’s access to education, political participation and divorce. Moreover some female employees do not agree with mullahs’ positions on divorce, polygamy and abortion.
So I propose to analyse these conflicts between different actors, only visible at the intimacy and interrelation level, and their impacts on constructions of new forms of citizenship. Because of corruption and because of these violences are considered as a private matter by police, lawyers and judges, because of fear of repression, a lot of spaces of public sphere denied domestic violence. So conflicts inside NGO for prevention of domestic violence remain inside NGO sphere which constitute uncertain space for activist women to bargain forms of male domination because of mollah’s presence.
Des savoirs au pouvoir. Réalisation quotidienne de la violence de l’Etat – au départ des cas de conflits fonciers entre les paysans et les élites politiques
Author: Aymar Nyenyezi Bisoka (Université catholique de Louvain)
A partir des cas concrets de conflits fonciers étudiés entre 2013 et 2014 en Afrique des grands lacs, le présent article tente de comprendre la manière dont les réformes foncières (règles et savoirs) étatiques génèrent de la violence dans des contextes pluralistes. En partant d’une brève analyse socio-historique, l’article revient tout d’abord sur les violences qui ont participé de la construction et de l’imposition des dispositifs fonciers en Afrique des grands lacs depuis leur déclenchement en 1884 (1). L’article revient ensuite sur la manière dont les résistances aux cadres légaux importés et imposés ont suggéré des formes de normes pratiques et de normes hybrides qui ont reconfiguré les cadres juridiques foncières dans un souci de cohabitation (2). L’article se concentre enfin sur des études de cas précis qui montrent la manière dont les intérêts et le pouvoir des élites politiques violent les droits des paysans en dérogeant régulièrement à ces arrangements socio-institutionnels. Si les intérêts des élites en question constituent la raison principale de cette violation, les savoirs produits par l’Etat et les logiques qui les sous-tendent en facilitent la réalisation (3).
How to subjugate women? Interconnected Sahelian ways
Author: Daniele Kintz (Université de Paris Ouest)
According to an appreciated West African way of speaking, two main « ways and means » of subjugating women are developing today:
• First, direct phone call between a migrant husband and his wife left at home, prevented by all means;
• Second, the withholding or confiscation of the wife’s administrative and legal documents by her family in law.
These two « ways and means » to subjugate women rests upon a dominant ideology denying autonomy of women in general and stating dependency of couples on the extended family in particular.
Considering the individual woman and the semi autonomous couple point of view these practices are indeed felt as expressions of social violence. But, the expected outcomes of these conservative practices (trying to bind tighter social ties) may not be reached. Indeed, all these strategies may lead to the opposite end result: the loosening of social links.
Intersectional violence, Pentecostal discourse and the everyday experiences of being a Romanian Roma in neoliberal Torino
Author: Cecilia Rubiolo (Università di Torino)
The paper is based on an extensive multisituated ethnography – 15 months between Torino (Italy), Ticvaniu-Mare and Vicov-de-Sus (Romania) – concerning everyday life of Romanian Roma born-again migrants living in the biggest « Nomad Camp » of Torino, La Barcaiola. « Radical uncertainty » is the paradigmatic figure which characterizes these migrants’ spatial and temporal horizons and is inextricably related to manifest and latent experiences of ordinary violence. The paper attempts to investigate the role of Pentecostal performative discourse in the « government of self and others » through an emphasis on individual autonomy and self-organization within a strict « regime of truth ». Such discourse mediates, through everyday ritualized practices, the Romanian Roma migrants experiences of suffering related to different forms of structural/symbolic/interpersonal violence to which they are exposed and re-signifies their sensation of radical uncertainty within the current neoliberal order governing their mobility; while at the same time producing a social imaginary which favours their integraton within a hierarchical, gendered and racialized political order and often neutralizing avert social conflicts which are embodied and internalized. The paper is based on participant observation and a collection of several life histories, with a special focus on conversion and migration.
Ontologies of violence: fighting with harmful traditions in Gurunsi widowhood rites
Author: Marko Veisson (University of Helsinki)
In the last decades modernising Gurunsi society in North-Eastern Ghana has been faced with changes like Christianization and increasing power of NGOs and the state government. These changes have brought new critical questions about traditional religious practices and traditional social structure. Practitioners of traditional religion are in a situation, where they have to give answers in completely new discourses influenced by the rhetoric of human rights and Christian moral.
Both critics and traditionalists are influenced by an understanding of the value of culture and tradition as such. Ghana is also proud of being religiously tolerant. So what is under critique is not traditionalism as a whole, but rather some violent (or mentally violent) and immoral practices of traditionalists.
My fieldwork has concentrated on discussions about widowhood rites and widow’s social position, which are important topics in this discourse, together with other harmful practices, such as witchcraft accusations. However, how well grounded are the accusations against traditionalists? It can be asked, whether widowhood rights are actually violence from the viewpoint of the traditionalists? Defining moral violence in another ontological system is problematic. In order to understand the local traditional viewpoint we have to take into account among other things the ways in which Western/Christian moral differs from traditional. For example, how does a different ontology of body and personhood influence the understanding of what happens during a ritual and whether what happens is interpreted as violence by the participants.
Ritual crimes and political violence in Gabon
Author: Maixant Mebiame Zomo
A partir d’enquêtes de terrain réalisées à Libreville, cette communication entend établir le rapport entre la pratique des crimes rituels et l’évolution de la vie sociale et politique du Gabon. Les crimes rituels sont des assassinats qui s’accompagnent des extorsions à vif d’organes d’Etres humains. Les organes recherchés dans ces cas (langues, lèvres, parties génitales, peau du crâne, etc.) ont une valeur ou une force symbolique (en lien avec la sexualité, la fécondité, le pouvoir) et sont voués à des usages dits fétichistes liés à la quête de puissance (ce qui n’exclut pas aussi un marché de ces « organes » fétiches, y compris du sang). La communication soutient que si la pratique de ces crimes dits « fétichiste » (Tonda, 2000 ; Bernault, 2005) stagnent à certains moments de la vie sociale, elle se développe surtout à l’approche des compétitions électorales. Outre la violence physique qui accompagne cette pratique, la communication revient précisément sur la vulnérabilité de certains acteurs prisés, les incertitudes et la peur qui habitent les habitants de Libreville.
Violence of witchcraft and inter-religious violence in the Central African Republic (2005-2014)
Author: Andrea Ceriana Mayneri (EHESS Paris)
The inter-religious violence that exploded in the Central African Republic at the end of 2012 has been described by the mass media as a clash between the Christian and Muslim communities. While violence is increasing in the country, a reading of the crisis in terms of a religious clash proves inappropriate for explaining the real reasons underlying this widespread violence. My research in the CAR from 2005 to the present has allowed me to analyze the violence of the accusations of witchcraft that are launched against an « other » – a neighbour, a colleague, a member of one’s own family – who is accused of being responsible for the ills and misfortunes that strike individuals and communities. An analysis of the violence of witchcraft and the violence of the inter-religious accusations allows us to shed light on the similarities and to conjecture a continuity between the two forms of violence. The « other » accused of witchcraft has gradually become a religious other (the Muslim or the Christian) as part of a discourse that is influenced, not only by economic and political interests, but by the rhetoric of the Pentecostal churches, with their obsessive insistence on the presence of evil and the need to combat it on every front. In this contribution I shall try to show how some of the combatants in the CAR (2013-2014) perceive this struggle as a « mystic » clash, fought with the weapons of witchcraft against an enemy, an « other » who is close at hand and persecutory
Violence, witchcraft and justice in Central Africa: the uncertainty of proof of guilty and innocence in witchcraft accusations (R.D. Congo, Central African Republic)
Authors: Sylvie Ayimpam (Institut des Mondes Africains (IMAf)
Jacky Bouju ( Aix Marseille Université)
This paper will concentrate on the issues of rationality in some witchcraft affairs. It is grounded on two training programs : the first on « witchcraft, violence and criminality » for High Courts Magistrates in Central African Republic funded by the European Union (2009-2011) and the second on Conflicts and Ordinary Violence (2007-2011) funded by French Research Agency. In Central Africa, witchcraft and spiritual beliefs contribute to the production of Development imaginaries and specifically to « mystical » ways of enrichment far different from the classical premises of instrumental rationality governing international development programs. Yet, people’s rationality is instrumental as they choose and implement actions that steer the future toward outcomes ranked higher in their preferences. Indeed, they maximize the convergence between their beliefs and reality and they act on these beliefs in such a manner as to maximize their chances of achieving their main goal: enrichment. But, the problem is that they are believed do so through magical beliefs and invisible actions and not through technical knowledge and visible actions as international development agencies would expect. The local theory about the mastery of these magical technics usually involves witchcraft practices that are considered by local traditions and by law as a great crime and therefore fought with greatest violence.